evenswr

Brazil:CC
Citizen Kane:SE
Godfather Trilogy
Star Wars: TPM
Evil Dead 2:SE
Monty Python'S Life of Brian:CC
Dracula(1931):SE
Monty Python and the Holy Grail:SE
White Zombie
Mallrats:SE

skar

1. Contact
2. T2: Ultimate Edition
3. Fight Club
4. Star Wars : Episode I
5. Requiem for a Dream : Unrated
6. American Beauty
7. Clerks : Uncensored
8. Election (my most watched DVD)
9. Titan A.E.
10. Pi

bjmumy

1. Gladiator
2. The Matrix
3. Shrek
4. Star Wars: The Phantom Menace
5. Toy Story Box Set
6. Cast Away
7. X-Men
8. The Fifth Element: Superbit
9. The Mummy: Ultimate Edition
10. Tomb Raider

platneon

1st - Se7en
2nd - Gladitor
3rd - Unbreakable
4th - Saving Private Ryan
5th - Antz
6th - Swordfish
7th - Matrix
8th - Fight Club
9th - Blade
10th - Pulp Fiction

Marquee Marq

1. Fight Club
2. Toy Story: Ultimate Box
3. Boogie Nights: 2 disc
4. Se7en : 2 disc
5. Magnolia
6. Do the Right Thing: Criterion Collection
7. The Evil Dead (Elite version)
8. Rushmore
9. Requiem for a Dream: Unrated
10. Mallrats

jiggyblau

1 Requiem for a Dream Unrated
2 American Beauty
3 Fight Club
4 Godfather Trilogy
5 Seven 2 Disc
6 Pi
7 Tommy Boy
8 Citizen Kane
9 Dogma 2 Disc
10 Monty Python and the Holy Grail 2 Disc

(I left out Sopranos and Simpsons because I chose to just go with stand alone movies, but they are really worthy of being up there!)

jarofclay73

1. Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace
2. Fight Club
3. Terminator 2 - Ultimate Edition
4. Snow White & the Seven Dwarfs
5. Se7en - Platinum Edition
6. Forrest Gump
7. Cast Away
8. Final Fantasy
9. Planet of the Apes (2001)
10. Shrek

Honorable mention: Thirteen Days

Will probably add before the year is up: Almost Famous - Director's Cut and Moulin Rouge

kenbuzz

Since the year isn't out yet, and since I'm betting that Moulin Rouge! will take over the #1 spot in my collection....


1st = Moulin Rouge
2nd = Henry V
3rd = Fight Club
4th = Hudson Hawk
5th = Monty Python and the Holy Grail (SE)
6th = This Is Spinal Tap
7th = Lion In Winter
8th = Repo Man
9th = Dark City
10th = Fawlty Towers

If Moulin Rouge! is ineligible because it's not *yet* released, then delete it, move everything up, and use Se7en as my new #10.

Sorry to make this complicated.

LBPound

Well since Moulin Rouge isn't out yet, I'll have to disqualify YOU! Just kidding....although by not counting it, you're breaking the three-way tie for 4th place that moves Se7en into 4th by itself.

Fur Q

1. Fight Club
2. Terminator 2: UE
3. The Matrix
4. Alien
5. Memento
6. Star Wars: Episode I
7. Aliens
8. South Park: BLU
9. & 10. League of Gentlemen Seasons 1 & 2

all based purely on replay value

darktrippers

Just to let you know.

Got an email from LBPound - who has regretfully been suspended from these Forums - asking me to relay the message that he is still tallying up the scores of this poll. Votes will stop December 15th.

Respect. And deepest commiserations. Moderators sometimes overstep the mark.

dt. (moderator, dv-depot).

JeTmAn

WTH???? Why was Lbpound banned???? Bring him back!!!

-JeTmAn

jarofclay73

Well, it's good to know that LBpound is still working posthumously on the top 100 DVDs on the DVD Talk Forum.

Blade

Explanation of LBPound23's banning:

http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/showthr...hreadid=162931

Obviously, I disagree with darktripper's assessment. But everyone's entitled to their opinion.

But yes, it is very decent of him to continue the tallying.

(edited to fix link -Blade)

darktrippers

First of all, David, the link doesn't lead to an explanation of LB's banning, so I really can't comment on this.

But...

As a Moderator on another major DVD Forum site - okay, not as major as DVD Talk - I know that cold detached sentences on the monitor can be misinterpreted as being malicious or hateful, but irony is a subtle artform. That's why Smileys were invented...to state the obvious.

In the past, I've fallen victim to LB's satirical wit...but it is all in good fun. He is a decent chap...honest.

So why don't you guys stop being stubborn, admit you
overreacted and un-ban him instead of rationalizing to
yourselves that it's beneficial to the site to not
have him here?

Blade

darktrippers,

Sorry about the bad link. I fixed it above, but here's the correct one: http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/showthr...hreadid=162931

I had posted this in the results thread for this poll too.

I really prefer handling these inquires via email and would request that if you have any further comments, that you email them to me.

I believe the above will provide a more complete explanation, but to address your point about irony and wit and overreaction...you are correct, it is hard to properly convey sarcasm and irony via the printed word. And even in face-to-face conversations, it can cause misunderstandings and arguments. But LBPound was not conveying his meaning without other members taking offense. He was asked to amend this and he did not. He was warned and suspended for this behavior and yet continued to practice it. He left us with no other option than to ban him.

So we were aware of the difficulties of communication via this medium, and I do not think that we overreacted.

I hope that addresses your questions of our actions, and I regret that things had to come to this, but LBPound was given ample opportunity and far more leeway than a new member would have received. And while I fully expect him to see this differently, he really brought this on himself.

-David

Zarley Zalapski

What ever happend to this? What are the Top 10 or Top 100 or whatever...Is Zarley Zalapski's greatest games the best DVD of all-time? If I don't hear anything then I will assume that it is

Tommy_Harn

1. Saving Private Ryan
2. Unbreakable
3. Memento
4. American Beauty
5. Good Will Hunting
6. Pulp Fiction
7. Almost Famous Bootleg Cut
8. Office Space
9. Braveheart
10. Requiem for a Dream

darktrippers

Saturday is your last chance to have your vote count
for the Top 100 DVDs census, which has become the most definitive list compiled by the online community.

So if you haven't voted yet, you're running out of
time!

A link to the results site will be posted on Sunday,
December 16.

Jocko6577

1. The Big Lebowski
2. Fight Club
3. Rushmore: CC
4. Godfather Trilogy
5. Pulp Fiction
6. Out of Sight CE
7. Rear Window
8. Unbreakable
9. Army of Darkness: LE 2DVD Set
10. Shrek

boobietheclown

1. Rushmore - CC
2. Citizen Kane
3. Gladiator
4. Dogma
5. Saving Private Ryan
6. Fight Club
7. Mallrats
8. Almost Famous - Untitled
9. Big Lebowski
10. This is Spinal Tap - CC

Hokeyboy

Geeze louise, this was tough to do.

My Top Ten DVDs:

1. Brazil: Criterion Collection
2. The Fantasia Anthology
3. Seven Samurai: Criterion Collection
4. Toy Story: The Ultimate Toy Box
5. Fight Club
6. Rushmore: Criterion Collection
7. This Is Spinal Tap: Criterion Collection
8. Snow White and the Seven Dwarves
9. Gladiator
10. Alien: 20th Anniversary Edition

Runnerups include: A Bug's Life: Collector's Edition, The Abyss, Beauty and the Beast: CC, Blade: Platinum Edition, Citizen Kane, Dark City, Emperor's New Groove: Collectors Edition, Lawrence of Arabia, North by Northwest, Spartacus: CC, Star Wars Episode 1: TPM, Superman: The Motion Picture, Terminator 2: UE, The Third Man: CC

In case anyone cares, here are my reasons:

1. Brazil - two versions of the film, great commentary, exhaustive supplements, and a classic look on how studio execs can knock the piss out of a great movie. Plus it's my favorite movie...

2. The Fantasia Anthology - the beauty of this is that both Fantasia and Fantasia: 2000, as standalone DVDs, are fantastic in and of themselves. Packaged together, plus an extra disc loaded with supplements, makes this one a no-brainer.

3. Seven Samurai - if you've seen it, you know why it's here. Throw in Michael Jeck's fantastic commentary -- still in my mind, the best ever recorded -- and you have what is definitely the most played DVD in my collection.

4. Toy Story: The Ultimate Toy Box - shorts, great commentaries, an infusion of Pixar spirit, fun, and energy, supplements galore, and two of the greatest films ever made? A great package.

5. Fight Club - great presentation of a great movie, lots of commentaries that are actually worth listening to, and supplements that are entertaining and informative without being fluffy. This is the stuff.

6. Rushmore: Criterion Collection - possibly one of the best single-disc DVDs ever created. I absolutely adore the menus and overall presentation of this disc. Not to mention a modern-day comedic classic of a film, great commentary, hilarious bits from the MTV Video Music Awards, and lots of the other worthwhile extras, Rushmore is a must-have.

7. This Is Spinal Tap: Criterion Collection - Despite the fact that I love the MGM version, with its anamorphic enhancement and WONDROUS commentary with the three mains in character, I still give CC the edge. Classic movie, two commentaries, the 20-minute promotional film, trailers, Heavy Metal Memories, and over an hour of deleted material. Plus no player-generated subtitles. I'm still kvelling...

8. Snow White and the Seven Dwarves - My god, Disney made this film look like it was created yesterday. And damn, if the story still doesn't hold up. The "immersive DVD experience" works, and works well, and the extras are great. I'm a total sucker for Walt Disney "commentaries" like the one here and on Fantasia. Gorgeous disc all around.

9. Gladiator - What a complete package. A favorite movie, in a dazzling transfer with rocking DD and DTS, great commentary by Ridley and friends, classy yet moody menus, and a host of fascinating documentaries and supplemental materials. Great set.

10. Alien: 20th Anniversary Edition - Another great single-disc edition; over 2 and 1/2 years old, but still holds up remarkably. The movie looks and sounds great, Ridley's commentary is irresistable, the extras are plentiful, and the menus that guide you through the Nostromo are schaweet.

JOE29

HERE ARE MY TOP 10 FAVORITES- 1-wAR OF THE wORLDS 2-13th Warrior 3-Bram Stokers Dracula 4-The Last of the Mohicans ( 1992 ) 5-The Birds 6-Wild Bill 7-Gettysburg 8-7th Voyage of Sinbad 9-What about Bob? 10-Stalag 17 This was very hard as I have many favorites from all decades of film.

garmonbozia

1. The Decalogue
2. Magnolia
3. The Godfather Collection
4. Brazil CC
5. Fight Club
6. The Wicker Man LE
7. Rushmore CC
8. Dead Ringers CC
9. The Thin Red Line
10. Alien

exConn

Bump

Looking forward to the results. I think voting ends today...

-exConn