View Poll Results: A Good Day to Die Hard - The Reviews Thread
0
0%
Voters: 63. You may not vote on this poll
A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
#51
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
#52
DVD Talk Hero
#54
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
This really should have been a movie where Willis teamed up with a Moscow detective to track down some sort of smugglers. Like a French Connection 2/ reverse-Red Heat type of movie but with more 'splosions.
#55
Suspended
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: California
Posts: 3,322
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
Actually this was the idea fpr the plot for the 4th Beverly Hills Cop movie except it would have had Axel Foley in London searching for some smugglers. They ended up scrapping the idea I guess and are now just doing a tv show.
#56
DVD Talk Legend
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
C'mon, I gave them plenty of extra credit for the best urban assault vehicle since Stripes and wrecking the most cars since Cannonball Run or Smokey and the Bandit. OK, I relent, five is stretching it no matter how you look at it.
#58
DVD Talk Legend
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
I saw it last night and thought it was just okay. It felt like it was missing something and I agree with someone I heard who said it almost felt like it was another script that was retooled as a Die Hard film. Overall it had some good action and Willis can still bring it. I'm curious about the director's cut that was referenced in that Empire article as it did feel like parts were missing and possibly cut.
Overall my ranking of the films thus far would be:
Die Hard
Die Hard with a Vengeance
Live Free or Die Hard
A Good Day to Die Hard
Die Hard 2: Die Harder
Overall my ranking of the films thus far would be:
Die Hard
Die Hard with a Vengeance
Live Free or Die Hard
A Good Day to Die Hard
Die Hard 2: Die Harder
#59
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
Amazing how far this series has coasted on only one truly classic movie.
#60
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
It's absolutely absurd that someone would rank this higher than Die Hard 2.
#61
DVD Talk Legend
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
#62
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
Well, this director certainly knows how to make a loud action movie, but not necessarily a good one. I gave it 2.5 stars, but I was being generous. This is easily my least favorite and the worst in the franchise IMHO. The car chase was fun but defied logic and physics. I would have liked a longer film that included character development. Instead, we got almost nonstop action that's over-the-top ridiculous at times, and a few moments that left me scratching my head: Why weren't the McClanes worried about exposure to radiation once the were inside the nuclear plant? Why weren't the McClanes injured at all when John purposefully blew up a room that had a gas leak? I suppose John fake laughing as a stall tactic right before he and his son were going to be shot was a nod to the original film, but it felt silly and forced. I got tired of John whining that he was on vacation. (I suppose he was on vacation as far as his employer was concerned even though we knew he was there to rescue his son.) I'm glad Mary Elizabeth Whitehead made a cameo as Lucy to further link the movies together, but I wish she'd played a bigger role. I'd like to see them tie everything up in a sixth film and close the series on a high note (if that's possible). I'd hate for the franchise to end with this one, which they could have called F@ck Off and Die Hard because it was an insult to the audience and nothing more than an attempt to milk the cow some more.
#64
DVD Talk Legend
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
I loved it! A Good Day To Die Hard is easily the best of the entire franchise. Even better than the first. The humor, the action, the setting - it's all fantastic!
OK, not really. But none of us were expecting it to be that good, were we?
I was hoping that it would match Live Free Or Die Hard, but it didn't.
For me the entire series has been slowly but surely declining the whole way through...
Die Hard - 5/5
Die Hard 2 - 4.5/5
Die Hard With A Vengeance - 4.25/5
Live Free or Die Hard - 4/5
A Good Day To Die Hard - 3.75/5
The bad guys were underwhelming (making the bad guy from Live Free look like Hans Gruber by comparison), the setting didn't feel AT ALL like a Die Hard movie, and worst of all - John McClane is relegated to sidekick status for much of the movie. He's just along for the ride. He's not leading the way, he's following his son's lead for much of the movie.
But there are some good (if totally ridiculous and over the top) action scenes and John McClane is wisecracking throughout (and that's a good thing as McClane is one of the most likeable action heroes in movie history).
As the movie moves at a breakneck pace it does have some solid entertainment value. It's not a total loss. It's not bad. It's just nowhere near what it should have been.
I still say that they should do one more and bring it full circle. Trap McClane in a building with the bad guys and actually let him be a detective like he was in the other Die Hard movies. An action movie detective, but a detective all the same. Scale it back. Make it more human. And spend a little more time developing the story and the script!
OK, not really. But none of us were expecting it to be that good, were we?
I was hoping that it would match Live Free Or Die Hard, but it didn't.
For me the entire series has been slowly but surely declining the whole way through...
Die Hard - 5/5
Die Hard 2 - 4.5/5
Die Hard With A Vengeance - 4.25/5
Live Free or Die Hard - 4/5
A Good Day To Die Hard - 3.75/5
The bad guys were underwhelming (making the bad guy from Live Free look like Hans Gruber by comparison), the setting didn't feel AT ALL like a Die Hard movie, and worst of all - John McClane is relegated to sidekick status for much of the movie. He's just along for the ride. He's not leading the way, he's following his son's lead for much of the movie.
But there are some good (if totally ridiculous and over the top) action scenes and John McClane is wisecracking throughout (and that's a good thing as McClane is one of the most likeable action heroes in movie history).
As the movie moves at a breakneck pace it does have some solid entertainment value. It's not a total loss. It's not bad. It's just nowhere near what it should have been.
I still say that they should do one more and bring it full circle. Trap McClane in a building with the bad guys and actually let him be a detective like he was in the other Die Hard movies. An action movie detective, but a detective all the same. Scale it back. Make it more human. And spend a little more time developing the story and the script!
#65
#66
DVD Talk Legend
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
The bad guys were underwhelming (making the bad guy from Live Free look like Hans Gruber by comparison), the setting didn't feel AT ALL like a Die Hard movie, and worst of all - John McClane is relegated to sidekick status for much of the movie. He's just along for the ride. He's not leading the way, he's following his son's lead for much of the movie.
#69
Moderator
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
#70
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
The villains had a weird magic thing that sucked the radiation out of rooms. Exactly how it worked was a mystery to me, but at that point it made as much sense as anything else that was happening in the movie.
#71
DVD Talk Hero
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
Speaking of long violent videogames (albeit one with copious amounts of exposition), anyone else picture Bruce Willis while playing Max Payne 3?
#72
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 9,334
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
Anybody defending this movie..uugh.
What a waste of a movie night. Finally, a night free of the kids and the wife, and I go see this pile of shit.
First, Bruce Willis is playing Bruce Willis, not John McClane. I guess he did this in 4 as well, but this time he just yells "i'm on vacation" like 10 times. That's it. Compare "I'm on vacation" with some of his quotes from the original..
Second, the movie employs every dumb cliche in the book.
What a waste of a movie night. Finally, a night free of the kids and the wife, and I go see this pile of shit.
First, Bruce Willis is playing Bruce Willis, not John McClane. I guess he did this in 4 as well, but this time he just yells "i'm on vacation" like 10 times. That's it. Compare "I'm on vacation" with some of his quotes from the original..
Second, the movie employs every dumb cliche in the book.
Spoiler:
#73
DVD Talk Legend
#74
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
The presence of a son is not an indication of anything. The presence of the daughter in the last one wasn't an indication of a spin-off, so why this, when he makes no references whatsoever to passing on the mantle or anything like that?
Of course, people think the moment at the end of Kingdom of the Crystal Skull -- a moment that is specifically and directly refuting the idea that Mutt would be a Jones replacement -- is doing that as well, so I guess there's no way to not make people think that.
Actually, they were referring to all the other movies: Die Hard was based on a book, and a sequel to The Detective, Die Hard 2 was based on an unrelated book by a different author, Die Hard 3 was a script called Simon Says and considered for Lethal Weapon, and Die Hard 4 was a script called ww3.com, as well as a Wired magazine article. This is the first Die Hard to be written solely as a Die Hard movie.
Of course, people think the moment at the end of Kingdom of the Crystal Skull -- a moment that is specifically and directly refuting the idea that Mutt would be a Jones replacement -- is doing that as well, so I guess there's no way to not make people think that.
Actually, they were referring to all the other movies: Die Hard was based on a book, and a sequel to The Detective, Die Hard 2 was based on an unrelated book by a different author, Die Hard 3 was a script called Simon Says and considered for Lethal Weapon, and Die Hard 4 was a script called ww3.com, as well as a Wired magazine article. This is the first Die Hard to be written solely as a Die Hard movie.
#75
DVD Talk Legend
Re: A Good Day to Die Hard (2013, D: Moore) - The Reviews Thread
Actually, they were referring to all the other movies: Die Hard was based on a book, and a sequel to The Detective, Die Hard 2 was based on an unrelated book by a different author, Die Hard 3 was a script called Simon Says and considered for Lethal Weapon, and Die Hard 4 was a script called ww3.com, as well as a Wired magazine article. This is the first Die Hard to be written solely as a Die Hard movie.
This one just seems forced. Like they were trying to fit in the conventional Die Hard plot ideas into another script or story. And that's ironic given the fact that it is really the first original story used in the series.
I don't think that A Good Day To Die Hard is a bad movie, but it is clearly the least worthy of the entire series, and isn't all that good, either. I'd hate for the series to end this way.