American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
#26
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 358
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
I don't get all the hate for Lil's name. I'm assuming it's short for Lillian. I don't think it's meant to mean "Little" like Lil' Kim. If anything, the judges and Ryan are the ones responsible for making her name seem obnoxious. Not her fault.
#27
DVD Talk Legend
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
I liked Ju'Not and Von Smith, even gave Ju'Not about 25 votes.
Dial Idol predictions:
Dial Idol predictions:
Spoiler:
#28
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
I thought Lil jinx.. er I mean Rounds was terrific
I like Scott a lot, his voice is ok, but he's easy to root for and should be a cinch to sail through the next few rounds, he has an embedded fan base already I am sure.
Carla has really grown on me I think she has been a worthy Judge addition and has even raised Paula's game, he responses are at least legible now.
Overall I thought this group was fairly strong, should be a good wild card round
I like Scott a lot, his voice is ok, but he's easy to root for and should be a cinch to sail through the next few rounds, he has an embedded fan base already I am sure.
Carla has really grown on me I think she has been a worthy Judge addition and has even raised Paula's game, he responses are at least legible now.
Overall I thought this group was fairly strong, should be a good wild card round
#29
DVD Talk Legend
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
#30
DVD Talk Hero
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
I agree that Kendall fits the niche better. Looking at her closer, she kinda does look like Kristen Chenoweth. She's kinda cute, just not really my type. She kinda reminds me of Kellie Pickler with the quirkyness and personality.
#31
DVD Talk Hero
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
I thought Lil jinx.. er I mean Rounds was terrific
I like Scott a lot, his voice is ok, but he's easy to root for and should be a cinch to sail through the next few rounds, he has an embedded fan base already I am sure.
Carla has really grown on me I think she has been a worthy Judge addition and has even raised Paula's game, he responses are at least legible now.
Overall I thought this group was fairly strong, should be a good wild card round
I like Scott a lot, his voice is ok, but he's easy to root for and should be a cinch to sail through the next few rounds, he has an embedded fan base already I am sure.
Carla has really grown on me I think she has been a worthy Judge addition and has even raised Paula's game, he responses are at least legible now.
Overall I thought this group was fairly strong, should be a good wild card round
#32
DVD Talk Legend
#33
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
changing the lyrics to "Call this show if you can't be without me, baby!" and getting a swell head from all the over the top praise is pretty obnoxious to me.
#36
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Guelph, Ontario
Posts: 9,921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
I hate to be a dick, because I do like Lil Rounds voice, but does the music industry really need another artist that sounds like this?
#37
DVD Talk Hero
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
#38
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
#39
Moderator
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
How long until Lil Rounds gets her Diva on and starts demanding we call her by one name (either "Lil" or "Rounds"). Or maybe we'll have to start calling her "L'il Lil".
#40
DVD Talk Hero
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
#41
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
I kinda have to agree with you here. She has the look and sound of hundreds of other black R&B artists. Even if she were to win, she will probably get lost in the shuffle like Fantasia.
#42
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
Only surprise for me there is:
Last night wasn't as bad as I feared. It helped greatly that the "screamers" (Von and Lil) reigned it in. Even the worst performances were at least bad in a funny way. And I know he's overrated vocally, but I find myself liking Scott. I get the sense he'd just as much not have a big deal made of his "sob story" ... and when AI does focus on it, he has a sense of humor about things. I have no doubt he'll be happily in the middle of the group number, flailing away with everyone else
And for tonight AI ... please, show at least some sense of drama. Don't tease out the whole night only to finish with: "There's one spot remaining ... WHO COULD IT BE?!?? Lil Rounds or Alex Wagner-Trugman?!?!?" From dialidol predictions, it sounds like the close finish between
would offer plenty of suspense and drama for them to be the last two in the show.
Spoiler:
Last night wasn't as bad as I feared. It helped greatly that the "screamers" (Von and Lil) reigned it in. Even the worst performances were at least bad in a funny way. And I know he's overrated vocally, but I find myself liking Scott. I get the sense he'd just as much not have a big deal made of his "sob story" ... and when AI does focus on it, he has a sense of humor about things. I have no doubt he'll be happily in the middle of the group number, flailing away with everyone else
And for tonight AI ... please, show at least some sense of drama. Don't tease out the whole night only to finish with: "There's one spot remaining ... WHO COULD IT BE?!?? Lil Rounds or Alex Wagner-Trugman?!?!?" From dialidol predictions, it sounds like the close finish between
Spoiler:
#43
DVD Talk Legend
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
And for tonight AI ... please, show at least some sense of drama. Don't tease out the whole night only to finish with: "There's one spot remaining ... WHO COULD IT BE?!?? Lil Rounds or Alex Wagner-Trugman?!?!?" From dialidol predictions, it sounds like the close finish between
would offer plenty of suspense and drama for them to be the last two in the show.
Spoiler:
#46
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: My Car
Posts: 6,750
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#48
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 358
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
I was merely pointing out the dislike for her name is unwarranted. Her personality may well be another issue entirely, and I'm not defending that at this point.
#49
DVD Talk Hero
#50
Moderator
Re: American Idol -- Group 3 of Top 36/Wild Card Show -- 3/3-3/5/09
Seacrest: "Arianna, Taylor, Alex, Kendall, and Scott... Please stand up. One of the five is in the Top 12. Who will it be?"
[Voice from the audience]: "SCOTT!"
[Voice from the audience]: "SCOTT!"