Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
#26
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
I went to see this on discount Tuesday, so I only wasted $6, but I did not like it. Maybe I'm not on Yorgos' wavelength. I certainly thought it was unique and creative and a singular artistic statement, but I was not entertained at all.
I don't understand how a film like this gets categorized as a comedy or even a black comedy. I think people just look at a movie that is weird and difficult to understand, and then just decide it must be a "black comedy." Being super weird does not equate to black comedy.
I will say this. IDK what Lily Gladstone is doing Flower Moon (haven't seen it) that could be a better acting performance than Stone.
I don't understand how a film like this gets categorized as a comedy or even a black comedy. I think people just look at a movie that is weird and difficult to understand, and then just decide it must be a "black comedy." Being super weird does not equate to black comedy.
I will say this. IDK what Lily Gladstone is doing Flower Moon (haven't seen it) that could be a better acting performance than Stone.
#27
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
Comes out on digital/PPV tomorrow
#28
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
Spoiler:
The following users liked this post:
Abob Teff (02-28-24)
#29
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
Wow, coming to Hulu before the Oscars!
The following 5 users liked this post by Decker:
Boondock Saint (02-28-24),
Damfino (03-08-24),
GoldenJCJ (03-02-24),
jpcamb (02-28-24),
Trelach24 (02-28-24)
#30
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
That is a short as heck PPV run but I am not curious to see the movie. Love Stone, Ruffalo and Dafoe and I had not heard about this movie yet. Glad I kept Hulu without commercials.
#31
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
Hulu has leaned hard into becoming more of an arthouse platform, thanks in large part to Searchlight, and I like that.
#32
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
I thought this was way too long at 2 hours, 16 minutes.
I didn’t like it as much as Yorgos previous films, but Emma Stone is so fucking fantastic in this that it doesn’t matter.
Dafoe is excellent here too.
I didn’t like it as much as Yorgos previous films, but Emma Stone is so fucking fantastic in this that it doesn’t matter.
Dafoe is excellent here too.
#33
DVD Talk God
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
I'll watch it on Hulu. I was never really that enticed to see it in the theater. I heard this movie is definitely not for everyone.
#34
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
(By the way, not trying to pick on you. Just genuinely interested in your thinking.)
#35
DVD Talk God
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
It may not be for everyone, and I definitely didn't like it as much as a lot of critics/etc., but my guy, you go to the movies so much. You see everything (sometimes twice) and are constantly advocating for theaters. You couldn't make time for one of the most acclaimed movies of the year? Again, I didn't love it, but it's a spectacular production and definitely rewards a big screen viewing.
(By the way, not trying to pick on you. Just genuinely interested in your thinking.)
(By the way, not trying to pick on you. Just genuinely interested in your thinking.)
I didn’t see a movie like Tar last year because the premise just didn’t interest me and I know it’s highly acclaimed.
#36
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
Yeah I try to see most big movies and a few smaller ones. Hell, I recently watched Anyone But You twice in the theater. But I’m not a big fan of eclectic arthouse type movies. Honestly I find most of them boring and this looked like one of those. I could be way off base in my assumption.
I didn’t see a movie like Tar last year because the premise just didn’t interest me and I know it’s highly acclaimed.
I didn’t see a movie like Tar last year because the premise just didn’t interest me and I know it’s highly acclaimed.
And everytime you see a Sydney Sweeney movie before seeing Tar, just know that a little part of my soul dies. Do you not want me to have a soul?
The following users liked this post:
Abob Teff (02-28-24)
#37
DVD Talk God
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
#38
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
But if you’ve ever wanted to see Emma Stone naked and having sex in many lol different 🍎 ways, that takes up about half the film. 😉
#39
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
Test it out. If you think this actually funny, not an interesting concept that makes you think about how odd it is, but actually ha-ha funny, this movie is for you.
#40
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
That made me uncomfortable.
#41
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
The movie is too long. I enjoyed the first half or so but it gets very repetitive. Sad to say Stone getting railed in multiple positions holds as much excitement as her expression during many of the scenes. For a movie about liberation and independence the movie fails to really capture any spirit of that by its conclusion instead feeling stylish but detached like a framed butterfly collection.
#42
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
Fair point, although that's the Lanthimos style. I also think that was somewhat by design: as she (rapidly) matures, the world becomes less exciting, there's repetition, her dialogue becomes more normal, etc.
The following users liked this post:
Nesbit (03-07-24)
#44
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
And Disney+ internationally!
#45
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
I liked it, but agree it could have been shorter. The parts on the boat and in Paris definitely could have been trimmed,
Stone and Dafoe were great, but Ruffalo could have taken it down a notch.
Stone and Dafoe were great, but Ruffalo could have taken it down a notch.
#47
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
This really clicked with me.
I unfortunately have the version with ads but in this case they actually kind of added to the experience of watching the movie. Things like Jerrod Carmichael telling Emma Stone he'd show her how the world works followed by a hard cut to a laundry detergent ad gave me as big of a laugh as anything in the movie and I laughed quite a bit.
Will be picking this up on bluray or 4k but may watch it with ads once more before I do.
I unfortunately have the version with ads but in this case they actually kind of added to the experience of watching the movie. Things like Jerrod Carmichael telling Emma Stone he'd show her how the world works followed by a hard cut to a laundry detergent ad gave me as big of a laugh as anything in the movie and I laughed quite a bit.
Will be picking this up on bluray or 4k but may watch it with ads once more before I do.
#48
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
I unfortunately have the version with ads but in this case they actually kind of added to the experience of watching the movie. Things like Jerrod Carmichael telling Emma Stone he'd show her how the world works followed by a hard cut to a laundry detergent ad gave me as big of a laugh as anything in the movie and I laughed quite a bit.
.
.
#49
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
Thanks, I saw that meme earlier and wasn't sure where it originated
#50
Enormous Genitals
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: a small cottage on a cul de sac in the lower pits of hell.
Posts: 37,202
Received 581 Likes
on
335 Posts
Re: Poor Things (2023, D: Lanthimos) S: Stone, Ruffalo, Dafoe
I thought Ruffalo was perfect, as were Stone and Dafoe. This is a weird, over the top, surreal morality play and it just works.