The 78th Annual Academy Awards Show Discussion
03-05-06, 10:25 PM
#502
DVD Talk Legend
I liked Crash (it was my #2 movie of the year), but to be honest, nothing this year really wowed me so if it goes to them, great...
03-05-06, 10:25 PM
#503
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Somewhere Hot Scoville Units: 9,999,999 Zodiac Sign: Capricorn
Posts: 12,259
Received 811 Likes
on
316 Posts
DVDTalk Oscar Pool Results:
Group Results
Group Rank Entry Predict Pts
1 Scoop-Li 19
1 Mr Cinema 19
1 mdc3000 19
4 PghBoy 18
4 Decker 18
4 Doctor Gonzo 18
4 Mao 18
8 zodiac_speak 17
8 MoviePage 17
8 ashmores 17
11 Highfire 16
11 MrMittman 16
11 scott1598 16
11 Geofferson 16
11 idrinkmolson 16
16 jpdude 15
16 lamphorn 15
16 Jericho 15
16 rkndkn 15
16 Dimitrios3 15
16 IspepAloc 15
22 Palaver 14
22 deadlax 14
22 zee 14
22 Eric D. 14
22 kitkat0 14
27 cloverclover 13
27 cool 13
27 quackers 13
27 Flay 13
27 jimdrix 13
32 Groucho 12
32 Joe Molotov 12
32 cinephan 12
32 beatccr 12
32 Lorenzol 12
37 maxfisher 11
37 Roper 11
37 rogue588 11
40 awm 10
40 $tarr 10
40 Chad 10
43 johnyboy 8
43 Tarantino 8
43 arsmith7 8
46 pilot 7
46 SpankyUT 7
46 peon73 7
49 RaraFemina 6
50 Entry 0
Group Results
Group Rank Entry Predict Pts
1 Scoop-Li 19
1 Mr Cinema 19
1 mdc3000 19
4 PghBoy 18
4 Decker 18
4 Doctor Gonzo 18
4 Mao 18
8 zodiac_speak 17
8 MoviePage 17
8 ashmores 17
11 Highfire 16
11 MrMittman 16
11 scott1598 16
11 Geofferson 16
11 idrinkmolson 16
16 jpdude 15
16 lamphorn 15
16 Jericho 15
16 rkndkn 15
16 Dimitrios3 15
16 IspepAloc 15
22 Palaver 14
22 deadlax 14
22 zee 14
22 Eric D. 14
22 kitkat0 14
27 cloverclover 13
27 cool 13
27 quackers 13
27 Flay 13
27 jimdrix 13
32 Groucho 12
32 Joe Molotov 12
32 cinephan 12
32 beatccr 12
32 Lorenzol 12
37 maxfisher 11
37 Roper 11
37 rogue588 11
40 awm 10
40 $tarr 10
40 Chad 10
43 johnyboy 8
43 Tarantino 8
43 arsmith7 8
46 pilot 7
46 SpankyUT 7
46 peon73 7
49 RaraFemina 6
50 Entry 0
03-05-06, 10:26 PM
#507
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Columbia Heights,MN
Posts: 474
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
anyone else feel that Jon Stewart died down big time with his enthusiasm as the nigth went on...not good for a host...i was worried his "delivery" of his humor might eventually not be able to carry the show...that and i bet they cut out some bits for time as ti looked like the producer said something to him at the end and Stewart kind of waved like "no big deal"
03-05-06, 10:27 PM
#509
DVD Talk Hero
Most predictable oscars ever.
03-05-06, 10:28 PM
#510
Member
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 167
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Didn't see Brokeback, can't comment. All I can say is I felt Crash was both transparent and simplistic. Deep Blue (I know, wrong year) was, in its soul, a far better comment on racism (and the first one that came to my head).
03-05-06, 10:28 PM
#511
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: San Leandro/San Francisco
Posts: 7,422
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally Posted by clckworang
Wow, Ben Stiller might be the worst presenter in Oscar history.
The Rap song that won? Horrible!
Crash did an upset. Good for it though I don't think it deserved it.
All and all I think the show was pretty boring.
03-05-06, 10:30 PM
#514
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by BrentLumkin
Now next year's show will really be interesting...
Ah, watching the Oscars with a TiVo on an hour and a half delay is the only way to go.
03-05-06, 10:33 PM
#517
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Traverse City, MI
Posts: 3,955
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I dont know why i watch these oscars every year they are always so boring. I should just watch all the shows afterwards that just show the best of moments.
03-05-06, 10:33 PM
#518
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Croissant!
Didn't see Brokeback, can't comment. All I can say is I felt Crash was both transparent and simplistic. Deep Blue (I know, wrong year) was, in its soul, a far better comment on racism (and the first one that came to my head).
03-05-06, 10:34 PM
#519
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by Croissant!
Not a surprise, shallow 'message' pictures usually do clean up around this time of year.
03-05-06, 10:43 PM
#521
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: Philadelphia, PA
Posts: 5,919
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
results I was most excited about:
#1 Wallace and Gromit!!!! yay!
#2 Brokeback Mountain winning best original score. all the other awards picked some boring score that totally didn't interest me.
#3 REESE!!!!!!!!!!!!
Big "Booooooooooooooooooooourns" for the following:
#1 Memoirs of a Geisha winning best cinematography and not The New World. academy voters suck.
#2 even though Philip Seymour Hoffman was a lock for best actor, I was still rooting for Joaquin.
#3 Crash winning best picture. Crash was a somewhat interesting and decent film, but it was probably the most mediocre film nominated. It was a pretty superficial film for the subject matter, and it didn't "wow" me on any level. Once again, for the most part, The Golden Globes pick better winners than The Academy Awards do.
This trend of spreading the awards around (especially splitting best picture and best director) is really sort of stupid and doesn't really mean anything. How can the best directed film not win any acting awards nor win best picture? It doesn't make logical sense. The director's main job is to guide the actors to get the best performances out of them. It would thus make sense that the person dubbed "best director" would have directed at least one "best performance" in presumably "the best film". All this divvying up the awards is just Hollywood trying to kiss as many of its own asses as collectively possibly. Vive The Golden Globes!!!! They gave best film awards to both Brokeback Mountain (Best Drama) and Walk the Line (Best Musical or Comedy).....both of which are well deserved.
#1 Wallace and Gromit!!!! yay!
#2 Brokeback Mountain winning best original score. all the other awards picked some boring score that totally didn't interest me.
#3 REESE!!!!!!!!!!!!
Big "Booooooooooooooooooooourns" for the following:
#1 Memoirs of a Geisha winning best cinematography and not The New World. academy voters suck.
#2 even though Philip Seymour Hoffman was a lock for best actor, I was still rooting for Joaquin.
#3 Crash winning best picture. Crash was a somewhat interesting and decent film, but it was probably the most mediocre film nominated. It was a pretty superficial film for the subject matter, and it didn't "wow" me on any level. Once again, for the most part, The Golden Globes pick better winners than The Academy Awards do.
This trend of spreading the awards around (especially splitting best picture and best director) is really sort of stupid and doesn't really mean anything. How can the best directed film not win any acting awards nor win best picture? It doesn't make logical sense. The director's main job is to guide the actors to get the best performances out of them. It would thus make sense that the person dubbed "best director" would have directed at least one "best performance" in presumably "the best film". All this divvying up the awards is just Hollywood trying to kiss as many of its own asses as collectively possibly. Vive The Golden Globes!!!! They gave best film awards to both Brokeback Mountain (Best Drama) and Walk the Line (Best Musical or Comedy).....both of which are well deserved.
03-05-06, 10:44 PM
#522
Crash won Best Picture? 
I think AMPAS voters must have gotten a bit nervous about Brokeback Mountain winning Best Picture for reasons unknown. This is the first time in over ten years a picture released early in the previous year won Best Picture (I believe Silence of the Lambs was the last to do so).
I think AMPAS voters must have gotten a bit nervous about Brokeback Mountain winning Best Picture for reasons unknown. This is the first time in over ten years a picture released early in the previous year won Best Picture (I believe Silence of the Lambs was the last to do so).
03-05-06, 10:44 PM
#523
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by TracerBullet
Why?
Ah, watching the Oscars with a TiVo on an hour and a half delay is the only way to go.
Ah, watching the Oscars with a TiVo on an hour and a half delay is the only way to go.
Clint Eastwood vs. Martin Scorsese
03-05-06, 10:44 PM
#524
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Michigan
Posts: 2,556
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My god you people are cynical. The hyperbole in this thread is ridiculous.
Stewart's opening monologue was wooden, but once he got comfortable, he was an entertaining and amusing host. The musical performances were well done. The montages, although a bit excessive, made me realize how much I love film.
Three 6 Mafia may have had the most hilarious reaction to winning an Oscar I've ever seen. You can crap on the "OMG RAP DUDES" winning an Oscar, but it's still something you'll remember years from now.
The right people won for Best Actor/Actress and Crash was a refreshing winner, since most pegged Brokeback to win it. Stiller, Ferrell, Carrell, Nicholson, Hoffman, etc. all did great jobs as presenters. Selma Hayek still beats around my emotions, though. As amazing as she looks, she's an absolutely terrible speaker, which makes it all the more obvious why she has a career in film.
Overall, a fun, brisk, and entertaining show that I thought delivered with the winners, too. A lot of you guys sound like Comic Book Guy with your pans of the show.
Stewart's opening monologue was wooden, but once he got comfortable, he was an entertaining and amusing host. The musical performances were well done. The montages, although a bit excessive, made me realize how much I love film.
Three 6 Mafia may have had the most hilarious reaction to winning an Oscar I've ever seen. You can crap on the "OMG RAP DUDES" winning an Oscar, but it's still something you'll remember years from now.
The right people won for Best Actor/Actress and Crash was a refreshing winner, since most pegged Brokeback to win it. Stiller, Ferrell, Carrell, Nicholson, Hoffman, etc. all did great jobs as presenters. Selma Hayek still beats around my emotions, though. As amazing as she looks, she's an absolutely terrible speaker, which makes it all the more obvious why she has a career in film.
Overall, a fun, brisk, and entertaining show that I thought delivered with the winners, too. A lot of you guys sound like Comic Book Guy with your pans of the show.
