chanster

Sorry, this one is even better. Marie Osmond made a great Leia. Not sure about Red Foxx as Obi-Wan though, or Kris Kristofferson as Han.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wOlui...eature=related

This must have been Lucas' motivation for the Holiday Special.

Spottedfeather

I hate to sound blasphemous, but I don't really mind the little changes like the blinking ewoks and the expanded cityview of Mos Eisley. But when you add lines like Vader yelling while saving Luke or add scenes that completely screw up the entire view of the movies like where you see Jabba in the movie when he wasn't in the movie originally. That's where I draw the line. The one single good thing about the blu-rays is they added back the Force fanfare during the attack on the Death Star.

Teremei

I admittedly didn't know much about this set. I was kind of a "maybe". I mean for one, I love 3D and I hear they are doing 3D, so why not just wait. Even then I was still thinking about it. Blinking Ewoks? Who cares, that's minor and is almost a cosmetic improvement (yeah I'm not a "purist").

But Darth Vader screaming while he kills the emperor? I look at that and think, Oh my God, how the **** is George Lucas so bloody rich? This guy is a terrible writer and director. The reason that scene was so cool is that Vader looked at his son and something finally snapped and he turned on his Master to save his son. The fact that he was silent, and the way the music is what was prominent in that scene is why it worked so well.

So here comes George thinking "heh heh, wouldn't it be cool if I tie in that NOOOO scream that he did in episode 6 with the scene in episode 3? That would be like so deep man it's like the movies are more connected!!" I mean my God he's got the creativity and brightness of an 8 year old boy. The totally ruins the scene. So my beef isn't with him adding new graphics to update the look, that I'm ok with. But when you **** with a scene like that. You make the movie worse. What he is doing is making them worse and worse every time he adds something stupid like this.

Rob V

Agreed. I'm also looking forward to the deleted scenes the most. I've seen the movies enough in the last 30+ years to be bored with it by now.

On a side note, did anyone catch the figures that were released as a Commemorative set for the Blu Ray release? Pretty cool.

Michael Corvin

I think that's the point most of us are trying to make Teremei. I'm fine with most of the cosmetic changes like Wicket blinking, or even "opening up" Cloud City, but once Lucas starts changing the tone and pacing of the films with shit like the "noooooo," adding a dance number, stopping for Vader to call his shuttle or putting Hayden in a film he wasn't even born before is beyond ridiculous.

I'm one of the few that likes Jedi. Sure it's the weakest of the OT, but it's still a fun romp, but these changes are getting out of hand.

milo bloom

I'm with you on ROTJ. It's showing signs of fatigue to be sure, but it's still a great flick, and Luke, Vader and Palpatine in the throne room is just great. That audio change is just too much. I'll live with the 2004 DVDs and VHS and LD for the originals.

I swear, even if they had just run those LD transfers through a commercial grade upconvertor so those "bonus" DVDs were 16x9, I would have bought them and let it go at that.

CharlieK

ENJOY!

wishbone

Han cooked first...

Nick Martin

I see no difference at all between that and Star Trek fans, or Harry Potter fans. Maybe Lord of the Rings fans as well, not sure.

Star Wars spawned that level of fandom, yes but it most certainly isn't the only one with fans who do those kinds of things.

Kal-El

One week away 'til this abomination hits the streets. How come there aren't any reviews out yet?

mcnabb

Exactly, Lucas didn't lose me with the smaller effect changes (I wasn't even annoyed with the new Jawa Sandcrawler or Obiwans hutt or the backround to Cloud City). But once he started replacing ACTUAL ACTORS AND DIALOGUE that is when he went too far. Adding in Hayden in the ghost scene, the awful Jedi Rocks, and now the new NOOO scream is jarring to anyone who has seen the films as much as we have.

I have to laugh at the Pro-Lucas defenders who say that any person who hasnt seen the films wont be bothered by the new changes when they first watch them, so they don't understand why we are getting all crazy about them.

My response, "No shit! If I didn't know my wife was cheating on me, I would think she was faithful!" Ignorance is bliss!

The Monkees

Stupid additions aside, I'm looking forward to this and I'm really excited!

EvlAsh

NiCK Crush

Sorry about your wife mcnabb, that's brutal. Hang in there.

Michael Corvin

steebo777

That's a bummer mcnabb, we should start up a support group or something.

bluetoast

An interesting video. Must have been fun for the kid. AICN pointed out the odd positioning of Hamill's light saber in certain shots.

<iframe width="420" height="345" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/MnTZwQjN2Jk?rel=0" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

TerryAlexFan

Have there been any pictures of the packaging (other than just scans of the front cover).

coli

I read somewhere that this release comes out September 16th? Isn't that a Friday, as I always thought BluRays and DVD's were released on Tuesday?

NiCK Crush

Sometimes they do special Friday releases. XMen First Class is being released this Friday, for example.

Supermallet

Why are people only complaining about it now, though? the 97 special editions had Jedi rocks and added/removed lines of dialogue, as well as things like Vader getting his shuttle and all that.

ScissorPuppy

People were complaining about it back in 97. The big deal was Han/Greedo scene, it overshadowed everything else as far as complaints go.

BuckNaked2k

^ Oh yea, the '97 changes were a big source of consternation for a lot of fans. Now, we've reached the point of fatigue due to the cumulative effects of all the changes we've endured, and a lot of folks are just giving this one a pass.

DthRdrX

I sometimes wonder if GL really changed the movies to fit his ever-changing "artistic vision" or if he just wanted to use new scenes/edits to push people into seeing the theatrical re-releases. Keep in mind back in 97 people had been without new Star Wars content for a long time and most fans seemed to want to see anything new that they could.

Michael Corvin

That and it was easier to shrug off because of two other reasons, one, it was still a chance to see it on the big screen and two it was the first and only time tweaks had been made.