Ignohippo

I would LOVE to know how many pre-orders have been cancelled.

I really hope it's enough to make Lucas take notice (even though (A) it won't make a difference and (B) he may just think he's better off because he knows how in demand the originals just became).

Ignohippo

Yeah but then people wouldn't buy the BS 2011 versions. By doing this, he's making it so you'll buy them now and then the restored originals in 10 years. So he's selling tons of us (and yes, I'm one of the retards that will buy both, as well as the 3d versions when those come out) a version we don't really want. He's doubling his money all from the same product.

The only way to have done it would have been to release both versions of each movie in the set at double the cost. I promise you though that sales would have been cut in half and people would be bitching about the cost.

The way he's doing it will keep him a money flow for the next 15+ years:

• Altered movies in HD - blu-ray (2011)
• Altered movies in HD - digital downloads (2012 or 2013)
• Altered movies in 3D - theaters (2012-2018)
• Altered movies in 3D - blu-ray (2019 or individually released each year through 2019)
• Originals restored in HD to blu-ray - 2020
• Originals restored in 3D to blu-ray - 2022

I'm telling you, this is all part of the plan.

Bob_Bobbson

Have you notices that the things people wanted fixed are simple FX clean ups (Like Saber color correction and crappy matte fixes)?

The thing is, Lucasfilm said they were working on this for years, and that they had fixed the most commonly complained about errors.

Now, it ends up that most of those errors are still there, but they spent time making Wicket blink and adding a CGI rock.

banthafett

Ive noticed that people say they want what they seen 30+ years ago, while at the same time want "simple clean ups and to fix errors". Cant have both.

pinata242

I can stomach corrections and restoration. I can even live with, but not thrilled with, CGI overlays for things like the X-Wings on the Death Star approach.

I'd be happy with the original movie cleaned up, touched up, even modernized... but I won't take all the other shit that goes along with it.

Drexl

That's a good point, and it might be a good poll subject. I would bet that some of those who want "the original versions" don't mind remixing the sound, or little corrections like fixing matte lines.

Personally, I would like to see the originals with some subtle corrections, but no new effects added, if that makes sense. In other words, keep the look of the original effects, but fix little mistakes and blemishes. And offer the original and remixed soundtracks.

Bob_Bobbson

That's what I was talking about. Fixing bad mattes, correcting wrong colored lightsabers, and color timing.

There is a difference between that and adding in new dialog or a 3 minute song & dance sequence.

lamphorn

I don't see any contradiction in being okay with minor corrections, like erasing matte lines, and juicing up the lightsabers, but being annoyed at new CGI characters muddling up the background and entirely new things being slapped on top of the movie, like Hayden in Return of the Jedi and now the NOOOOO over Darth throwing the Emporer over the rail.

The "NOOOO" sealed the deal for me. Cancelled my preorder. I'm done. That was the worst cheesiest moment in Revenge of the Sith and now they've brought that over into the climax of Jedi?? Over and out.

That Citizen Kane package is looking better and better every day.

Michael Corvin

It's all about subtle tweaks. Things that most people don't even know about and probably wouldn't even notice when watching it.

gmanca

A new version of changed scene:
<object width="560" height="345"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/LF4YGIg-lZA?version=3&hl=en_US&rel=0"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/LF4YGIg-lZA?version=3&hl=en_US&rel=0" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" width="560" height="345" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true"></embed></object>

Nick Martin

That worked flawlessly. Brilliant stuff!

nmr1723

Agreed. I'm only keeping my preorder because I was able to use that B&N 50% off coupon in May. For $48...I think it's still worth it.

As for a possible poll...I'd rather have the originals with all the mattes, errors, etc. Sure, these things might stand out in HD...but that wouldn't stop me from watching them as long as the audio is solid and not the compressed stereo track from the '06 bonus discs. I'd take the originals with LPCM stereo in all its glory any day of the week.

Ideally, we would get this "Blade Runner" style and have all the cuts. That would be f'n awesome.

Doctorossi

I can't believe their promotion is leading with "Look- we fixed the lightsaber shots!" when the shots they previewed are practically the only ones they fixed. Did the the Lucasfilm marketing department just come back from the "How To Anger Your Customers Unnecessarily" conference?

PopcornTreeCt

Nice thought but I doubt Blu-rays will still be around in 10 years. Hopefully in the year 2020 I'll at least be able to stream the originals restored.

nmr1723

Agreed. Plus, I thought I read somewhere that 3D versions of the rest of the saga would only be made if "The Phantom Menace" 3D was successful. I can possibly see TPM do well since it was the first prequel and it was made (in my opinion) for a younger audience...but who is going to see a forgettable movie like "Attack of the Clones" in 3D?

I'll be very surprised if we see the full saga in 3D...

lamphorn

Just had an earthquake in L.A. because of the "NOOOO" news.

Sonic

Now Vader seems more like Frankenstein.

leem6453

Still #1 on Amazon best sellers list. We ain't changin' shit.

Drexl

The Vader change is now on the front page at Yahoo.

TGM

do you think that pedophile priests use the term "George Lucas raped my childhood"?

nodeerforamonth

You mean "Frankenstein's monster".

Sorry but I guess I just had to add to the anal retentiveness of this thread.

Solid Snake

I fucking get sooo annoyed that they call the monster Frankenstein. I've hated that since I was a little kid.

kefrank

I guess I got alteration fatigue earlier than most. I didn't bother picking up the original trilogy DVDs until this past year, when I finally bought the slim-pack trilogy on the cheap to have the unaltered originals on disc (even in crappy quality).

I've always loved Star Wars, but have never been a hyper-obsessive fan nor have I ever intimated that George Lucas is any kind of rapist. I simply prefer the original trilogy with all of its original issues. I probably will not get the Blu-ray box set. At least not until it drops in price considerably, when I might buy it for the extras.

Supermallet

Someone tweeted my daughter about it and she replied that it "was always spelled that way. It's just fans who keep the debate alive."

K&AJones

Well FWIW...over on the Amazon boards they are ripping this a major "A-Hole". I'm willing to bet that Amazon has never had to deal with a cancellation of this magnitude before.

As they say..."Sh#t rolls down hill"...and I'm sure the Lucas Ranch will be getting it soon and has plenty of space for it"