Phantom Menace to be released in 3D Next Spring
#351
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
#352
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
I understand you put a lot of thought into your post, I respect you coming to their defense and you made some salient points, but...Episode 2 and 3 were not really good. They were terrible movies. The writing, direction, dialogue and acting were all substandard. And I'm being kind.
#353
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
I think people way overanalyze the faults of the Prequels. The biggest failing of the trilogy comes down to this: Bad Characters. The success of any movie comes down to its characters and story, and I could give a rats ass about any of the characters in the PT (although Obiwan was the one guy I kinda cared about).
I said in the spring of 99 to many friends that the PT will not be as good as the OT simply because there is no Luke, Leia and Han, and there is nothing Lucas can do about that since it takes place before they were all born. Lucas created magical characters in the OT and it is next to impossible to create another trilogy of great characters that fans can care for. If you don't care about the characters, then why do you care what happens in the next 2 hours? Now many will argue that the PT is a tragedy and Anakin eventually turns to a bad guy, so it is tough to get an audience to care about him. I would then argue that any mob movies has bad guys the audience is forced to care for (The Godfather, Goodfellas, heck even Scarface.)
Padme and Both Anakins were a failure as characters and whenever I see a PT movie on Spike, they had the EXACT opposite effect that Luke, Leia and Han did for me as a viewer. This is essentially why Lucas should have never made the PT, because there was no way he was going to be able to create another trilogy of lovable characters.
I said in the spring of 99 to many friends that the PT will not be as good as the OT simply because there is no Luke, Leia and Han, and there is nothing Lucas can do about that since it takes place before they were all born. Lucas created magical characters in the OT and it is next to impossible to create another trilogy of great characters that fans can care for. If you don't care about the characters, then why do you care what happens in the next 2 hours? Now many will argue that the PT is a tragedy and Anakin eventually turns to a bad guy, so it is tough to get an audience to care about him. I would then argue that any mob movies has bad guys the audience is forced to care for (The Godfather, Goodfellas, heck even Scarface.)
Padme and Both Anakins were a failure as characters and whenever I see a PT movie on Spike, they had the EXACT opposite effect that Luke, Leia and Han did for me as a viewer. This is essentially why Lucas should have never made the PT, because there was no way he was going to be able to create another trilogy of lovable characters.
#354
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
I understand you put a lot of thought into your post, I respect you coming to their defense and you made some salient points, but...Episode 2 and 3 were not really good. They were terrible movies. The writing, direction, dialogue and acting were all substandard. And I'm being kind.
#355
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
I think people way overanalyze the faults of the Prequels. The biggest failing of the trilogy comes down to this: Bad Characters. The success of any movie comes down to its characters and story, and I could give a rats ass about any of the characters in the PT (although Obiwan was the one guy I kinda cared about).
#356
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
Agreed. I quite liked Qui-Gon, but he wasn't really given much to do.
#357
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
GL had too many characters in the PT. Almost every successful movie that tries to be epic always concentrates on a few characters to tell their story.
qui gon and maul should never have been in the story. along with grievous and/or dooku. GL should have had one helper for palpantine. boy anakin should never have seen the light of day.
other than bad and non-important characters the story is broken up. the clone wars just seems to happen for no reason. the invasion of naboo as well. there are explanations but nothing to tie the movies together
qui gon and maul should never have been in the story. along with grievous and/or dooku. GL should have had one helper for palpantine. boy anakin should never have seen the light of day.
other than bad and non-important characters the story is broken up. the clone wars just seems to happen for no reason. the invasion of naboo as well. there are explanations but nothing to tie the movies together
#358
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
GL had too many characters in the PT. Almost every successful movie that tries to be epic always concentrates on a few characters to tell their story.
qui gon and maul should never have been in the story. along with grievous and/or dooku. GL should have had one helper for palpantine. boy anakin should never have seen the light of day.
other than bad and non-important characters the story is broken up. the clone wars just seems to happen for no reason. the invasion of naboo as well. there are explanations but nothing to tie the movies together
qui gon and maul should never have been in the story. along with grievous and/or dooku. GL should have had one helper for palpantine. boy anakin should never have seen the light of day.
other than bad and non-important characters the story is broken up. the clone wars just seems to happen for no reason. the invasion of naboo as well. there are explanations but nothing to tie the movies together
#359
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
And the syfodious thing pissed me off. On Theforce.net there was a big deal about him before the movie. In the movie they never really said why the clones were created in the first place. And Antilles only had a few lines.
The whole pt went back and forth on trying to tie everyone in the ot to each other and just dropping other details that could have been important.
But then if you watch all the gl interviews he's always going on about technology and not the story.
The whole pt went back and forth on trying to tie everyone in the ot to each other and just dropping other details that could have been important.
But then if you watch all the gl interviews he's always going on about technology and not the story.
#360
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
And the syfodious thing pissed me off. On Theforce.net there was a big deal about him before the movie. In the movie they never really said why the clones were created in the first place. And Antilles only had a few lines.
The whole pt went back and forth on trying to tie everyone in the ot to each other and just dropping other details that could have been important.
The whole pt went back and forth on trying to tie everyone in the ot to each other and just dropping other details that could have been important.
1.) Dooku gets furious over his old padawan's death and blames the Jedi Order for only sending two Jedi into that mess on Naboo, even going to the Senate with his complaints. No one helps him. He leaves the Jedi order and even contemplates tracking down the missing Sith Lord himself.
2.) Sidious actually contacts him and Dooku, who is so angry with the Jedi/Senate, gets convinced that he needs to take things on himself to fix everything wrong in the galaxy. (Remember in Ep2 Dooku tries to rationalize to Obi-Wan that his evil actions against the Republic are ok because a Sith Lord is actually manipulating them via the senate. He wants to kill Sidious and control everything his way at this point, hence trying to get Obi-wan's help)
3.) Master Syfo-Dyas, who is an member of the Jedi Council and friend of Dooku, either orders the clones as requested by Dooku and then is betrayed and killed to cover it up, or he is betrayed and killed and Dooku uses his name to order the clones.
4.) Dooku recruits Jango as Clone template as requested by Sidious.
The main problem is the movies paint Dooku as a 'clone' of Sidious, right down to the force lightning. His 'character' is lost as nothing more than a throwaway to bridge a spot in the movies, a physical threat, between Maul's death and Sidious finally making himself known.
Personally, I wish Dooku was either in EP1 or Maul had not died. As is, it's hard to watch the movies and understand why Dooku would become a Sith directly after Qui-gon's death at the hands of one. Remember he still speaks very highly of Qui-Gon in the movie.
The alternative is that you could have Anakin witness Maul kill Qui-Gon in Ep.1, cut off Anakin's hand in Ep.2, and have a final memorable confrontation with Anakin in Ep.3. This would have mirrored Luke seeing Obi-wan killed by Vader(ANH), getting hand cut off by Vader (TESB), and having a final memorable confrontation. (ROTJ)
Instead we got a bunch of characters with little buildup/story. (MAul/Dooku/Grevious)
#363
Banned by request
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
Saw the trailer for this before Hugo. When it finished, an old guy behind me said, "That's two hours of Jar-Jar in 3D. Is there anything Lucas won't milk for cash?"
![LOL](/images/smilies/lol.gif)
#365
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#366
DVD Talk Legend
#367
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
Tarkin and Vader seemed to be equals. But Vader in ANH was hardly the untouchable killing machine he was in the later two films. He even let that star destroyer commander ("Holding her is dangerous!") argue with him without choking him. I'm more confused as to how he gained so much political power after the death star debacle.
#368
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
Filmgoers thought he was cool and because of that he went from mere henchman to main badguy in the sequel. Simple as that and about as logical as Obi-Wan's "certain point of view" bullshit to explain how he outright lied to Luke about what happened to his father.
#369
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
Tarkin and Vader seemed to be equals. But Vader in ANH was hardly the untouchable killing machine he was in the later two films. He even let that star destroyer commander ("Holding her is dangerous!") argue with him without choking him. I'm more confused as to how he gained so much political power after the death star debacle.
If that particular commander had built up a relationship with Vader over time, Vader might be more inclined to let some comments slide here and there. Even in Empire he's not lashing out wildly, he's targeting his choking at people that are specifically pissing him off.
#371
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 5,512
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#372
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
Is anyone who is grown up actually going to see this???? I understand if anyone has kids to take to see it, but for any SW fan who is continues to support Lucas with this crap ![Brick Wall](/images/smilies/brickwl2.gif)
Lucas talking to Rick McCallum after the opening weekend of Episode I 3-D, "Wait, the theaters are sold out and it made 50 million over the weekend? Geez, I could piss on the seats in the theater and these people will still come to see anything with Star Wars attached to it!"
![Brick Wall](/images/smilies/brickwl2.gif)
Lucas talking to Rick McCallum after the opening weekend of Episode I 3-D, "Wait, the theaters are sold out and it made 50 million over the weekend? Geez, I could piss on the seats in the theater and these people will still come to see anything with Star Wars attached to it!"
#373
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
Lucas talking to Rick McCallum after the opening weekend of Episode I 3-D, "Wait, the theaters are sold out and it made 50 million over the weekend? Geez, I could piss on the seats in the theater and these people will still come to see anything with Star Wars attached to it!"
#374
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#375
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012
Re: Star Wars: The Phantom Menace...in 3-D for 2012