Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
#951
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
I agree that they should have mapped out a cohesive story for this sequel as step 1; it’s absurd they didn’t. But at the same time I’m not sure it’s fair to compare the franchise with Marvel/Fiege like that. He has like 80 years worth of comics to pull inspiration from or to loosely adapt. But if Star Wars tried to pull too much from the Legends books and comics, fans would be in an uproar. I know some stuff has made it into the new canon like Thrawn, I mean like more if this trilogy tried to actually pull it’s overall story straight from the Thrawn or New Jedi Order book trilogies.
I really don’t believe most fans would be happy with a new canon that’s just a retread of the old canon, with the exception of KOTOR.
I really don’t believe most fans would be happy with a new canon that’s just a retread of the old canon, with the exception of KOTOR.
#952
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
It's not really JJ's fault The Last Jedi didn't go the way he wanted...apparently, he had some ideas but Rian went in a different direction and KK let him run with it.
I can see why he almost said "no" to IX though. You want to tell your story, but you have to figure out a way to tell it so it doesn't contradict the movie a lot of people hate and which you had very little to do with. He's almost in a no-win situation.
I can see why he almost said "no" to IX though. You want to tell your story, but you have to figure out a way to tell it so it doesn't contradict the movie a lot of people hate and which you had very little to do with. He's almost in a no-win situation.
#953
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
It's been said a trillion times... Financial Success does not mean it was a good movie. The "vocal minority"?? Just read the posts under almost every single Youtube video regarding Ep 8. And yes, I get that there are boneheads and Russian trolls posting many negative things... but it's a generally divisive movie, not one that is undermined by a minority. Other message boards seem to have the exact same fallout as DVD Talk.
#954
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
I agree that they should have mapped out a cohesive story for this sequel as step 1; it’s absurd they didn’t. But at the same time I’m not sure it’s fair to compare the franchise with Marvel/Fiege like that. He has like 80 years worth of comics to pull inspiration from or to loosely adapt. But if Star Wars tried to pull too much from the Legends books and comics, fans would be in an uproar. I know some stuff has made it into the new canon like Thrawn, I mean like more if this trilogy tried to actually pull it’s overall story straight from the Thrawn or New Jedi Order book trilogies.
I really don’t believe most fans would be happy with a new canon that’s just a retread of the old canon, with the exception of KOTOR.
I really don’t believe most fans would be happy with a new canon that’s just a retread of the old canon, with the exception of KOTOR.
I'm not a big fan of TLJ, but I will be even more mad if JJ starts to retcon everything in Episode 9 as it will make Trilogy look even more uneven. At this point just go with Random Rey, Force Ghost Luke, RIP Snoke, and move the story along. The worst thing they could do at this point is reach for straws that Rey is somehow related to somebody from the OT just please those fans that were disappointed she wasn't. All of this stuff is bogging down the movies in this Trilogy as they are forced to spend time answering questions that were never fully developed instead of moving the plot along. The Rey/Kylo scenes in TLJ are great, and then you have this big anti-climatic reveal of her parents that would never had been needed to be addressed if that mystery box didn't exist from TFA.
#955
Senior Member
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
There no way Episode 9 bombs like Solo (simply because the Saga movies appeal more to the masses), but I just don't know if it can equal TLJ box office numbers? Can we really see Episode 9 grossing 650-700 million domestic and 1.4-1.5 billion worldwide as that is what it will take to beat TLJ?
I didn't see Solo (edit - in a theater) based on how disappointed I was in TLJ. Unless early word is exceptionally good, I can see skipping Episode IX as well.
#956
DVD Talk Gold Edition
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
It's been said a trillion times... Financial Success does not mean it was a good movie. The "vocal minority"?? Just read the posts under almost every single Youtube video regarding Ep 8. And yes, I get that there are boneheads and Russian trolls posting many negative things... but it's a generally divisive movie, not one that is undermined by a minority. Other message boards seem to have the exact same fallout as DVD Talk.
It's devisive amongst SW fans, sure, but the vast majority of people who saw TLJ really don't give a shit, and probably didn't think about it after leaving the theater.
We may not see as much from people who liked the movie, but I'd guess it's because engaging in this ridiculous back and forth with the narrow minded segment of this particular fanbase is exhausting and pointless so why bother.
Last edited by lopper; 04-11-19 at 09:01 AM.
#957
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
I don't think anyone expected them to have this 'Lord of the Rings' timeline of all 3 movies mapped out, as SW has never been like that (even in the Lucas days). What makes fans like me mad is that obviously JJ had ideas for Rey, Snoke, and other plot points he setup in TFA and Rian Johnson just took them and did whatever he wanted with them.
1. JJ Abrams' MO is that he sets up mystery boxes and doesn't actually have ideas for where they should go, so I think it's wrong to assume he had specific ideas for Rey, Snoke and other plot points he set up in TFA.
2. I'm not going to argue all the details again, because I've made my points in the TLJ thread which you can go read again if you care to, but what Rian Johnson chose to do with Luke, Rey, Snoke, etc in TFA was absolutely a logical progression of what Abrams set up in TFA. It may not have been what some vocal fans wanted or had built up in their mind, but the plot surrounding those characters across the two movies (and even in light of the OT) flows very well, with interesting and well-developed themes, if you simply take the movies as they are and don't muddle them with jackass fan theories and obsessive speculation.
#958
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
You're nuts if you think people posting on message boards and YouTube are anything but a vocal minority. It's a remarkably small sample size in the grand scheme of people who saw TLJ.
It's decisive amongst SW fans, sure, but the vast majority of people who saw TLJ really don't give a shit, and probably didn't think about it after leaving the theater.
We may not see as much from people who liked the movie, but I'd guess it's because engaging in this ridiculous back and forth with the narrow minded segment of this particular fanbase is exhausting and pointless so why bother.
It's decisive amongst SW fans, sure, but the vast majority of people who saw TLJ really don't give a shit, and probably didn't think about it after leaving the theater.
We may not see as much from people who liked the movie, but I'd guess it's because engaging in this ridiculous back and forth with the narrow minded segment of this particular fanbase is exhausting and pointless so why bother.
#959
DVD Talk Gold Edition
#960
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
Perhaps... but it's something. It's not like message boards (which are pretty much the ONLY outlet for us fans to discuss this stuff) are loaded with people claiming it's a great movie. It's about 50/50 or so here... and probably much the same on rational message boards and probably much less on troll sites like Youtube. So the proclamation that not liking Ep 8 is a minority is misguided.
#961
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
I mean, when Solo had issues, what do they do? Hired a veteran Hollywood blockbuster director to finish it up. When Trevorrow shit the bed? Go back to Abrams. For Rogue One they brought in a veteran script fixer in Gilroy, and apparently trusted him to film his fixes more than the original director.
Lucasfilm ran into problems with the spin-offs and Ep 9 because they took risks on the directors, and when they ran into problems, went back to someone more established.
https://film.avclub.com/a-tony-stark...ive-1833595458
What’s fascinating about the Hulk scene, then, is how thoroughly it accomplishes its goals, despite the fact that nothing that happens in it actually matters, or even makes a lick of sense. Despite Stark’s offer of implied recruitment, Thunderbolt Ross wouldn’t show up in the MCU again until Captain America: Civil War, eight years and 11 films later—by which point Hurt was essentially playing an entirely different character, far removed from the cartoonish Javert chasing Norton’s Hulk around. Even Tony’s status as an ostensible Avenger(s?) recruiter is mostly baffling, in light of his distance from the project at the start of Iron Man 2.
Marvel also has the benefit of mining decades of comic book material. The first time Thanos shows up at the end of Avengers, comic fans knew it would lead to Infinity War, because it was already told in the comics. For Lucasfilm, their original EU focused so much on the period immediately after original trilogy that they don't have material to mine for a 30-years-later movie revival. So it's all original, with no storyline already established that they can just steal and rejigger a bit to fit.
#962
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
Perhaps... but it's something. It's not like message boards (which are pretty much the ONLY outlet for us fans to discuss this stuff) are loaded with people claiming it's a great movie. It's about 50/50 or so here... and probably much the same on rational message boards and probably much less on troll sites like Youtube. So the proclamation that not liking Ep 8 is a minority is misguided.
#963
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
And the reverse is also true. You don't see as much from those on the boards who disliked it as they realized early on wasn't worth the time and effort to get into a ridiculous back and forth with those who are so condescendingly dismissive.
#964
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
Well if you want to go with statistics, in the TLJ reviews thread, 66% of DVD Talkers who rated it gave it 3.5 stars or above. If you add in the 3-star ratings, it jumps to 82%. Just going by the mathematical definition, it is in fact a minority here who disliked the movie enough to rate it less than 3 stars and it's not really very close to 50/50, FWIW.
#965
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
This isn't TLJ thread. Please don't turn it into one.
#966
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
All I'm going to say is, this is an odd response. I simply stated the exact numbers from the poll on DVD Talk as a data point that refutes your 50/50 assertion (which had no data). If you would like to point out where I "skewed" anything in those numbers, feel free to shoot me a PM so that we don't muck up this thread anymore with TLJ discussion. I'm open to being corrected and I'll edit my post if I erred.
#967
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
All of this stuff is bogging down the movies in this Trilogy as they are forced to spend time answering questions that were never fully developed instead of moving the plot along. The Rey/Kylo scenes in TLJ are great, and then you have this big anti-climatic reveal of her parents that would never had been needed to be addressed if that mystery box didn't exist from TFA.
Still hoping for the best from Ep9, and an awesome trailer tomorrow.
#969
DVD Talk Gold Edition
#970
#971
DVD Talk Legend
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
I'm not a huge critic of these films but ugh, that would be a horrible name. It's not RoTJ or RoTS. I guess it's to be expected because these names have so far been completely underwhelming.
#972
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
I'm actually interested to see how I react to this trailer today. EVERY SW trailer has worked for me in some way (even the PT movies) as they were able to craft it in a way that made me nostalgic, yet looking forward to what is coming. I'm really bearish on Episode 9 and the ST right now, but the one thing that can 'Michael Corleone' me back to this franchise is a damn good trailer.
As he said in Godfather 3, "Just when I thought I was out.....they pull me back in!!!"
As he said in Godfather 3, "Just when I thought I was out.....they pull me back in!!!"
#973
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
<iframe width="702" height="395" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/1Xj9vF4aoCA" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe>
...
...
#974
DVD Talk Legend
#975
DVD Talk Special Edition
re: Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker (12/20/19, W/D: J.J. Abrams)
Should be "Whill of the Force" to pay tribute to both the Journal of the Whills from the original film's novel and also the Whills from George's apparent original plans for the sequel trilogy...
![Wink](/images/smilies/wink.gif)